Find the Best Accommodations in Shelter Island, NY

Call To Book 

Shelter Island, NY, USAdd DatesChange Search
Destination: Shelter Island, NY, US(change)
Select Date
Select Date
2 adults
0 children
1 room
Groups: Need 5+ Rooms?
  • 50 Available Shelter Island Hotels
  • Rates Starting at just $100
  • Last Minute Inventory!
- See More -
 
SUNSET BEACH
$525
starstarstarstar
0 Reviews
35 Shore Road Shelter Island, NY
Call to Book:
West Neck Guesthouse
$100
starstarstar
0 Reviews
31 West Neck Rd Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
Dering Harbor Inn
$100
starstar
0 Reviews
13 Winthrop Road Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
Shelter Island House
$100
starstarstar
0 Reviews
11 Stearns Point Rd Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
Seven a boutique B & B on Shelter Island
$100
starstarstarstar
0 Reviews
7 Stearns Point Road Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
House on Chase Creek
$100
starstar
0 Reviews
3 Locust Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
The Chequit
$511
starstarstar
0 Reviews
23 Grand Ave Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
The Pridwin Hotel
$314
starstarstar
0 Reviews
81 Shore Road Shelter Island Heights, NY
Call to Book:
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast
$100
starstarstar
0 Reviews
424 4th Street Greenport, NY
Call to Book:
The Harborfront Inn
$288
starstarstar
0 Reviews
209 Front St Greenport, NY
Call to Book:
Loading More Hotels
Filtersclose
Hotel Name
Price
Stars
Rating
Amenities
Chain
Searching for the lowest rates.
Show Map
Loading Map
 
Hotels in Nearby Cities
Hotels Near Landmarks